Autopsy vs Foremost vs Scalpel: Which File Carving Tool tool is Best in 2025?

Autopsy is an open-source digital forensics platform and graphical interface to The Sleuth Kit (TSK), pre-installed on Kali Linux at /usr/bin/autopsy. Developed by Basis Technology and Brian Carrier, it provides a user-friendly web-based GUI for analyzing disk images and file systems, including Windows (NTFS, FAT), UNIX (EXT2FS, EXT3FS, FFS), and mobile devices (Android, iOS). Used by law enforcement, military, and corporate investigators, Autopsy facilitates evidence recovery, timeline analysis, and case management for cyber forensic investigations. Its intuitive design and real-time results make it a cornerstone for ethical hackers and forensic analysts.

Foremost is an open-source, command-line file carving utility pre-installed on Kali Linux at /usr/bin/foremost, designed for recovering deleted or hidden files from disk images and storage devices. Originally developed by Jesse Kornblum, Kris Kendall, and Nick Mikus for the U.S. Air Force, Foremost uses data carving techniques to identify and extract files based on their headers, footers, and internal structures, bypassing file system metadata. Widely used by digital forensic investigators, incident responders, and ethical hackers, it supports formats like PDF, JPG, MP3, and executable files, making it essential for cyber forensic investigations and data recovery.

Scalpel is an open-source, high-performance file carving utility pre-installed on Kali Linux at /usr/bin/scalpel, designed for recovering deleted or hidden files from disk images and raw block devices. Developed by Golden G. Richard III as an enhanced rewrite of Foremost 0.69, Scalpel leverages header and footer signatures to extract files, bypassing file system metadata. Supporting formats like JPEG, PDF, MP3, and DOC, it’s a critical tool for digital forensic investigators, incident responders, and ethical hackers conducting cyber forensic investigations and file recovery. Scalpel’s multithreading, GPU acceleration, and regular expression support make it exceptionally fast and versatile.